I dare say mine was Kay Hanley of Letters To Cleo. I can remember being SO smitten when I finally got a chance to see her in person, in a super small bar called Chelsea's back in Columbus(I think it is literally a Starbucks now...so cliche and so sad).
The actual crush though probably started the second I saw the video for their modest es/9hit, 'Here And Now'...it was love at first sight. That cool alt-rock haircut, her thrift store sense of style, and that sweet voice...yeah, I never had a chance!
In the name of nostalgia, here is that song...and one other LTC tunes off of their follow up album, 'Wholesale Meats and Fish'